Educational content only. Nothing here is personal investment advice. Read the disclaimerFree to read, no sign-up needed

Gold as an investment: bonds, ETFs, digital gold and jewellery compared

Gold earns nothing on its own, yet it is in almost every Indian portfolio. How much to hold, and which form makes sense.

Indian households hold gold for reasons that have little to do with spreadsheets: weddings, festivals, safety, tradition. As an investment, gold behaves differently from shares and bonds. It pays no dividend and no interest, and its price can stay flat for years. What it offers is a cushion. It often holds its value when other assets struggle, and it protects against a weaker rupee.

How much to hold

Many planners suggest somewhere between 5 and 10 per cent of your investments. Beyond that, gold starts to drag on long-term growth. Count only what you hold as an investment. Jewellery you will wear and keep is a different matter, and including it can give you a false sense of how much you already own.

The options

FormHow you hold itMain advantagesWatch out for
Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB)Government security, in grams of goldPays 2.5% a year on the issue price on top of gold's price change; government-backedLong maturity; early exit only on specified dates or via the exchange, where liquidity can be thin and prices can sit below gold
Gold ETFUnits in your demat accountTracks the gold price, easy to buy and sell on exchanges, small annual chargeNeeds a demat account; small tracking gap
Gold fund (fund of funds)Mutual fund that invests in gold ETFsNo demat needed; SIPs are possibleTwo layers of cost
Digital goldHeld with an app or sellerTiny purchase amountsNot regulated like a security. Spreads can be wide, and you depend on the seller's vault and honesty.
Physical coins and barsYou store themYou hold the real thingMaking charges, storage and purity checks
JewelleryYou wear or store itUse and sentimental valueMaking charges of several per cent, deductions on resale; a poor investment

The state of SGBs

For years, SGBs were the best-regarded way to hold gold, thanks to the 2.5 per cent interest and favourable tax treatment on redemption at maturity. The government has not been issuing new tranches in recent times, so new buyers can only get SGBs from the secondary market. That means checking the price against the underlying gold value, the interest still payable and the remaining term. Tax treatment of gold instruments has also been changed more than once. Check the current rules before you buy or sell anything.

Gold ETF or gold fund?

If you already have a demat account, a gold ETF is usually the simplest and cheapest way. If you don't, or if you want to invest through a SIP, a gold fund of funds is easier though costs a little more. Compare the expense ratio and the tracking difference.

About digital gold

Digital gold is easy to buy in a few taps, and that convenience is why it's popular. But it generally isn't regulated like a mutual fund, ETF or SGB, and the regulator has warned investors about this. If you use it, keep amounts small, use a well-known seller and treat it as a convenience, not a core holding.

Buying jewellery wisely

If you do buy jewellery, look for BIS hallmarking, which certifies purity. Ask for the making charge and wastage in writing. Compare the rate with the day's market price. Keep the bill, because resale value depends on proof of purity and weight.

Gold in the bigger picture

A simple approach

Decide your target share (say 5 to 10 per cent). Buy gold ETF units or a gold fund through a monthly SIP. Rebalance once a year. If gold rises sharply and now makes up more than you wanted, sell a bit and move it back into equity or debt. That discipline of selling after a rally is difficult, and it's the real benefit of having a target.

Gold prices are volatile and have long flat or falling periods. Rules on SGB issuance, taxation and the regulation of digital gold change often. Verify current details with RBI, SEBI and the Income Tax Department.

This article is for general education and is not personal advice. Found a mistake or an out-of-date number? Tell us and we will check it.